"Should I be worried about the home inspection?" This is THE question that keeps sellers up at night after accepting an offer. Will they find something major? Will the buyer walk away? Will I have to make expensive repairs?
Inspection day doesn't have to be stressful when you know what to expect. After helping hundreds of sellers navigate inspections in both Xenia and Yellow Springs, I've learned that preparation beats panic every time.
What Is a Home Inspection?
A home inspection is a thorough examination of your property's condition, typically conducted by a licensed inspector hired by the buyer. The inspector examines the home's major systems and components, then provides a detailed report documenting their findings.
Most purchase contracts include an inspection contingency, which gives the buyer the right to:
- Have the home professionally inspected
- Request repairs based on inspection findings
- Renegotiate the price
- Cancel the contract if significant issues are discovered
In Ohio, buyers typically have 7-14 days after contract acceptance to complete their inspection and make repair requests.
What Do Home Inspectors Actually Look For?
Inspectors examine these major areas:
Structural Components:
- Foundation (cracks, settling, water intrusion)
- Roof condition and estimated remaining life
- Walls, floors, and ceilings
- Windows and doors
Major Systems:
- HVAC system operation and age
- Plumbing (leaks, water pressure, drain function)
- Electrical system (panel capacity, wiring, outlets)
- Water heater age and condition
Safety Issues:
- Carbon monoxide and smoke detectors
- Handrails and guardrails
- GFCI outlets in bathrooms and kitchens
- Proper venting for appliances
Additional Items:
- Attic insulation and ventilation
- Basement or crawl space moisture
- Grading and drainage around the home
- Gutters and downspouts
Local Concerns in Xenia and Yellow Springs:
- Older homes often have outdated electrical panels (fuse boxes vs. circuit breakers)
- Basement moisture is common in our area due to Ohio clay soil
- Many historic Yellow Springs homes have unique features that may not meet modern codes (but are often grandfathered in)
- Older Xenia homes may have lead paint (pre-1978 construction). Note: Federal law requires specific disclosures for homes built before 1978 regarding lead-based paint hazards.
Understanding Inspection Reports
A typical inspection report is 20-50 pages long and includes:
- Photos documenting issues
- Descriptions of problems found
- Recommendations for repairs or further evaluation
- Safety concerns highlighted separately
Important distinction: Not everything in an inspection report requires action. Inspectors note:
- Major issues requiring immediate repair
- Safety hazards that should be addressed
- Maintenance items (normal wear and tear)
- Informational notes about how systems work
Buyers cannot demand repairs for every item listed. The inspection contingency typically covers "material defects"—significant problems that affect the home's safety, structure, or value. Material defects have specific legal definitions in Ohio; consult your agent for details relevant to your situation.
Common Inspection Findings in Our Area
Based on my experience with local properties:
Xenia homes frequently show:
- Older HVAC systems (15+ years)
- Basement moisture or foundation cracks
- Outdated electrical systems
- Roof wear on older homes
Yellow Springs properties often have:
- Older well and septic systems
- Unique structural features in historic homes
- Wood-burning stove or fireplace issues
- Grading and drainage concerns
Most of these are normal for our area and don't typically derail sales when handled properly.
How to Handle Repair Requests
After the inspection, buyers typically submit a repair request or inspection resolution. Here's how to approach it:
Step 1: Review the Request Carefully
Work with your agent to categorize requests:
- Safety issues (should usually be addressed)
- Major system failures (negotiable)
- Minor repairs (often rejected)
- Maintenance items (typically not the seller's responsibility)
Step 2: Consider Your Options
You can:
- Make all requested repairs (rarely necessary)
- Make some repairs (most common approach)
- Offer a credit instead of making repairs
- Reduce the sale price
- Decline all requests (risky but sometimes appropriate)
- Provide a combination (fix some, credit some, decline others)
Step 3: Respond Strategically
Your response should consider:
- Market conditions: In a seller's market, you have more negotiating power
- Property price: Higher-priced homes often come with higher repair expectations
- Issue severity: Safety hazards should generally be addressed
- Your timeline: Do you need this sale to close quickly?
- Buyer's commitment: Are they genuinely concerned or trying to renegotiate?
When to Negotiate vs. When to Stand Firm
Consider negotiating when:
- The issue is a legitimate safety hazard
- A major system is failing or near the end of its life
- The problem wasn't disclosed and the buyer couldn't have known
- The repair cost is reasonable relative to the sale price
- You want to maintain good faith and close the deal
Stand firm when:
- Requests are unreasonable or excessive
- Items are cosmetic or preference-based
- Issues are normal wear and tear for the home's age
- Problems were already disclosed
- Buyer is asking you to upgrade rather than repair
- The home was priced considering its condition
Example from my practice: A buyer in Xenia requested $8,000 in repairs after inspection, including replacing a 12-year-old HVAC system "because it's old" and repainting the entire interior "due to scuff marks." The seller countered by agreeing to fix the roof leak ($1,200) and repair a plumbing issue ($600) but declined cosmetic requests and the HVAC replacement since the system worked fine. The buyer accepted, and the sale closed successfully.
Red Flags in Repair Requests
Watch for buyers who:
- Request repairs for every item in the inspection report
- Ask you to "bring everything up to code" (not required unless it's a safety issue)
- Want upgrades rather than repairs
- Demand unrealistic timelines for repairs
- Request cash back at closing for repairs (must comply with lender requirements and RESPA regulations)
These may indicate a buyer trying to renegotiate or looking for reasons to cancel.
How to Prepare Your Home for Inspection
Before the Inspection:
- Ensure utilities are on and accessible
- Clear access to attic, basement, and crawl spaces
- Make sure the inspector can reach the electrical panel, water heater, and HVAC
- Fix obvious issues (leaking faucets, loose handrails)
- Replace burned-out light bulbs
- Clean or replace HVAC filters
- Test smoke and carbon monoxide detectors
During the Inspection:
- Leave the property (buyers and inspectors prefer privacy)
- Take pets with you
- Leave the home clean and uncluttered
- Provide documentation of recent repairs or system maintenance
After the Inspection:
- Don't panic when you see the report length
- Review it carefully with your agent
- Focus on significant issues, not minor items
- Respond professionally and promptly
Working with Licensed Contractors
If you agree to make repairs:
- Use licensed, insured contractors (buyers often require this)
- Get written estimates before agreeing to work
- Keep all receipts and warranties
- Have work inspected if required by the agreement
- Provide documentation to the buyer at closing
Don't hire "your buddy" who'll do it cheap. Buyers want professional repairs with warranties.
The Pre-Listing Inspection Option
Some sellers choose to have a pre-listing inspection before putting their home on the market. Benefits include:
- Identify and fix issues on your timeline
- Reduce negotiation surprises
- Show buyers you're transparent
- Potentially speed up the sale process
However, in Ohio you must disclose the pre-listing inspection results even if they reveal problems. Discuss this strategy with your agent.
Special Considerations for Investment Properties
If you're selling a rental property in Xenia (like I've done), inspections often reveal:
- More wear and tear than owner-occupied homes
- Deferred maintenance issues
- Tenant-caused damage
Price your investment property accordingly and be prepared for more extensive repair requests.
What Happens If You Can't Reach an Agreement?
If negotiations fail:
- The buyer may exercise their inspection contingency and cancel
- You keep their earnest money only if they cancel outside the contingency period
- Your home goes back on the market
- You must disclose inspection findings to future buyers in Ohio
This is why most sellers and buyers find middle ground rather than walking away.
Understanding Your Disclosure Obligations
Important: If the inspection reveals issues you didn't know about, you must now disclose them to future buyers if this sale falls through. This is another reason to consider negotiating rather than refusing all repairs.
Tips for a Smooth Inspection Process
- Respond promptly to repair requests (typically within 2-3 days)
- Be reasonable in your negotiations
- Prioritize safety issues over cosmetic concerns
- Provide documentation for past repairs and maintenance
- Stay calm and trust your agent's guidance
- Focus on major issues, not every minor item
- Consider the buyer's perspective while protecting your interests
Final Thoughts
Home inspections are a normal, expected part of the selling process. Most inspection reports contain 20-30 items, but only 2-5 typically become negotiation points. The key is approaching inspection negotiations strategically rather than emotionally.
In my experience selling properties in both Xenia and Yellow Springs, the vast majority of inspection negotiations end successfully when both parties act reasonably. Buyers understand homes aren't perfect, and sellers understand that legitimate concerns deserve attention.
Remember: The buyer has already chosen your home and made an offer. They want the sale to work. Inspection negotiations are usually about finding fair middle ground, not killing the deal.
Your agent's job is to help you navigate these negotiations professionally and strategically. Trust their experience, respond promptly, and focus on what truly matters—completing a successful sale.
The inspection phase typically lasts 7-14 days. It might feel stressful, but it's just one step in the journey to closing. With the right approach and realistic expectations, you'll get through it successfully.
Disclaimer: This blog is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Always consult with your licensed real estate agent and attorney for guidance specific to your situation. Real estate laws and requirements may vary and change over time.